No, a steak should never be chewy. If you just cut into one and had to work your jaw to get through it, something specific went wrong between the counter and the plate. It is not a flaw in steak as a category. The two most common causes are cooking past the point where that particular cut can stay tender, and slicing the finished steak the wrong direction. Both are fixable tonight, and one takes about ten extra seconds of attention with the right tool.
The Real Reasons a Steak Turns Out Chewy
Chewiness almost always traces back to one of four things. Overcooking tightens the muscle fibers and pushes out moisture, so a steak taken past medium keeps getting tougher the longer it sits on the heat. A lean cut with little marbling or connective tissue was never going to feel as tender as a ribeye no matter how carefully it was cooked. Slicing with the grain instead of across it leaves long muscle strands intact, and your teeth end up doing the work a knife should have done. And resting it wrong, either not at all or based on a formula that does not apply to a single steak, lets juices run out onto the cutting board instead of back into the meat.
Most guides stop at “don’t overcook it.” That advice is true and not especially useful, because nobody grills a steak intending to overcook it. The real fix is removing the guesswork, and that starts with knowing the exact temperature the steak is at, not the color you think it looks like through smoke and firelight.
Hit the Right Internal Temperature Every Time
These are the internal temperatures that separate tender from chewy for most steak cuts. Pull the steak off the heat about 5°F before the target, since carryover cooking will finish the job while it rests.
- Rare: 120°F to 125°F, pull at 115°F to 120°F
- Medium rare: 130°F to 135°F, pull at 125°F to 130°F
- Medium: 140°F to 145°F, pull at 135°F to 140°F
- Medium well: 150°F to 155°F, pull at 145°F to 150°F
- Well done: 160°F and up
The USDA’s minimum safe temperature for a whole cut of beef is 145°F with a 3 minute rest, which lines up with medium. Anything you cook past that is a preference call, not a safety one, and every degree past medium is a degree closer to chewy.
This is where a fast, accurate instant read thermometer earns its keep. Guessing by touch, or cutting a slit into the steak to peek at the color, are both common habits, and both are how steaks overshoot their target. Cutting into the steak early also lets the juices run out before the meat has had a chance to hold onto them, which makes the texture worse on top of the guesswork problem. A thermometer that reads in about a second means you can check without leaving the steak on the heat long enough to lose the window.
The ThermoWorks Thermapen ONE is worth the higher price for anyone who grills steak often. It reads in about one second, the display auto-rotates so it is readable from any angle, and the probe is thin enough that it does not leave a wide channel for juice to escape. For a tighter budget, the Alpha Grillers Instant Read Meat Thermometer gets a reading in one to two seconds and is accurate enough to solve the same overshoot problem for a fraction of the cost.
If you want a side by side look at more options, including wireless probes for thicker cuts and roasts, see our full guide to the best digital meat thermometers.
The Cut Matters More Than the Cook
Ribeye, New York strip, filet mignon, and porterhouse all have enough fat marbling or a naturally tender muscle structure that they forgive small cooking mistakes. Chuck, round, flank, skirt, and hanger steak do not have that cushion. Those cuts are leaner, carry more connective tissue, and will taste chewy at medium rare no matter how good the thermometer work was, because a quick high heat cook does not give collagen time to break down.
That is not a reason to avoid the cheaper cuts, especially if the budget matters more than the cut on a given week. It just means they need a different plan. A 30 minute to overnight acidic marinade, something with citrus, vinegar, or buttermilk, softens the exterior fibers on flank and skirt steak before it hits the grill. Reverse searing, low heat first and a hard sear at the end, gives thicker chuck or round cuts more time near temperature for connective tissue to soften without overcooking the center. Treating a tough cut like a quick sear candidate is the single most common reason people end up chewing through dinner.
None of this requires a full outdoor setup either. A cast iron skillet on a stovetop burner handles the same cuts the same way, which matters if you are grilling in an apartment, a rental with no yard access, or anywhere else an open flame is not an option. The thermometer and the resting rules below apply exactly the same indoors.
Slice Across the Grain Before You Blame the Steak
This is the fix for a steak that is already resting on the cutting board and still turns out tougher than expected. Look at the raw surface before you cut and find the direction the muscle fibers run, they show up as fine parallel lines. Turn the steak so those lines run left to right, then slice straight down through them into thin pieces. Cutting with the grain instead of against it leaves those long fibers whole, and it is often the actual reason a properly cooked flank, skirt, or hanger steak still feels chewy at the table.
A sharp, straight edge knife makes this easier to do cleanly, since a dull blade drags through the fibers instead of cutting them, which tears the meat rather than slicing it. If your current steak knives have started dragging instead of cutting, our guide to the best steak knives covers straight edge options built for clean cuts on grilled meat.
Rest It by the Clock, Not by the Pound
A single steak does not need 10 minutes of rest per pound. That math is meant for a whole roast or a turkey, and applied to a 6 to 10 ounce steak it would mean resting for well under a minute, which is not enough time for anything. Tent a steak loosely with foil and give it 5 to 10 minutes regardless of its weight. That is enough time for the juices pushed toward the center during cooking to redistribute through the whole cut, so they stay in the meat instead of pooling on the cutting board the moment you slice it.
If You Only Change One Thing
Buy an instant read thermometer and use it on every steak, every time. It fixes the overshoot that causes most chewy steaks, and it removes the habit of cutting into the meat early to check, which was working against you twice. If tonight’s steak is already a tougher, leaner cut, slice it thin against the grain before you decide it is a lost cause. That combination, a known internal temperature and a correct cut, solves the problem for good.
Last update on 2026-08-15 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
This post contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using these links.
