When it comes to pellet grills, Traeger and Weber are two of the most recognized names in the industry. Both brands offer unique features and benefits that appeal to different grilling enthusiasts. This article compares Traeger and Weber, diving into their key differences and helping you decide which one is the right choice for you. Additionally, we touch on other brands available in the market to give you a well-rounded perspective.
Table of Contents
Why Compare Traeger and Weber?
Traeger has been a pioneer in the pellet grill market for decades, known for its innovation and reliability. While Traeger excels in pellet grills and smokers, it isn’t as prominent in the broader outdoor grill market.
On the other hand, Weber has built a strong reputation with its high-quality charcoal and gas grills, backed by excellent customer service. Recently, Weber entered the pellet grill market, challenging Traeger’s dominance.
Pellets account for a lesser percentage of the BBQ industry than well-established competitors such as charcoal and gas grills. However, the growing popularity of pellet grills indicates a shift towards more versatile and flavorful grilling options.
Traeger Ironwood 650 vs. Weber SmokeFire EX4
We compared the Traeger Ironwood 650 and Weber SmokeFire EX4, two popular models with similar cooking surface areas and Wi-Fi connectivity. Our extensive testing included cycling the grills on and off, smoking brisket at 250°F, and grilling chicken wings at 500°F to understand their performance.
Design and Features
Traeger Ironwood 650:
- Traditional design with a side table and pellet hopper.
- Sturdy construction with large, thick legs.
- Two large rubber wheels and steerable casters for easy movement.
- Lacks a chimney, venting smoke out the back for a cleaner look.
- Control panel on the side of the pellet hopper.
Weber SmokeFire EX4:
- Barrel-style design resembling a beer keg.
- Pellet hopper runs along the back.
- No chimney, with smoke venting out the rear.
- Stainless-steel grill grates and a heat deflector plate.
- Exposed grill area for smoking or searing.
Both grills showcase thoughtful design elements, but their construction styles cater to different aesthetic preferences. Traeger’s robust build offers durability, while Weber’s sleek design enhances its appeal on any patio.
Grilling Space
Grilling space is a crucial factor when investing in a pellet grill.
Weber SmokeFire EX4:
- 672 square inches of grilling space (432 on the bottom grate, 240 on the top rack).
Traeger Ironwood 650:
- 572 square inches of grilling space (418 on the bottom grate, 154 on the top rack).
When spending over $1,000 on a grill, the cooking area becomes a significant consideration. Weber provides a larger grilling space, making it suitable for hosting larger gatherings.
Pellets
Both grills can hold a 20-pound bag of pellets and feature easy unloading gates for flavor changes.
Weber Pellets:
- Cost: $16.99 per 20-pound bag.
- Flavors: Apple, hickory, cherry, mesquite, and a “grillmaster’s mix.”
Traeger Pellets:
- Cost: $18.95 per 20-pound bag.
- Flavors: Pecan, apple, hickory, cherry, mesquite, and a “signature mix.”
While both brands offer a variety of flavors, Weber’s pellets are slightly more affordable, providing an economical advantage for frequent grillers.
Wi-Fi Connectivity and App Functionality
Both models offer Wi-Fi connectivity, allowing you to control the grill and monitor cooking through their respective apps.
Traeger App:
- User-friendly with built-in recipes and step-by-step instructions.
- Highly rated for its intuitive interface.
Weber Connect App:
- Simpler interface but equally effective.
- Includes many recipes but slightly less user-friendly than Traeger’s app.
The apps’ built-in recipes are particularly helpful for beginners, offering guided cooking experiences. However, experienced grillers may appreciate Traeger’s more comprehensive app features.
Temperature Control and Heat Retention
Both grills excel in maintaining consistent temperatures during long smoking sessions. They include Bluetooth and Wi-Fi applications for easy temperature adjustments.
Traeger Ironwood 650:
- Features a ‘Super Smoke’ button for intense smoke at low temperatures.
- Warms up and recovers faster once the lid is opened.
- Maintains consistent temperatures within 10°F of the set point.
Weber SmokeFire EX4:
- Exhibits temperature fluctuations up to 50°F.
- Control panel readings are less precise than Traeger’s.
The Traeger Ironwood’s ability to maintain consistent temperatures and recover quickly from lid openings makes it a reliable choice for serious grillers. In contrast, Weber’s temperature fluctuations may require more attention during cooking.
Price
Weber SmokeFire EX4:
- Priced at $799.
Traeger Ironwood 650:
- Priced at approximately $1,200.
The price difference is significant, making Weber a more budget-friendly option while Traeger offers advanced features and consistent performance for a higher investment.
Warranty
Weber SmokeFire EX4:
- Offers a five-year warranty covering material defects (excludes cosmetic damages and normal wear and tear).
Traeger Ironwood 650:
- Provides a three-year warranty, valid only for the original owner and excludes improper use.
Weber’s longer warranty period offers better protection and peace of mind for your investment.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Pellet Grills
Advantages:
- Consistent smoke flavor due to indirect heat.
- Wi-Fi connectivity for remote monitoring and control.
- Easy pellet flavor switching.
Disadvantages:
- Slower heat-up compared to gas grills.
- Less portable due to reliance on electricity.
- Limited searing capability.
Pellet grills offer a unique cooking experience with a focus on flavor and convenience, but they may not suit everyone’s needs, especially those looking for quick heating or portability.
Final Verdict
Both Traeger and Weber offer high-quality pellet grills with unique strengths. The Traeger Ironwood 650 stands out for its robust construction, consistent temperature control, and user-friendly app. It excels at both low and high-temperature cooking, making it a versatile choice for serious grillers.
Weber SmokeFire EX4, while more affordable, offers a large grilling area and solid performance at lower temperatures. However, it struggles with consistent high-temperature cooking, making it less reliable for tasks requiring precise heat control.
In conclusion, if you’re looking for durability, advanced features, and consistent performance, the Traeger Ironwood 650 is the better choice. If budget is a concern and you primarily smoke at lower temperatures, the Weber SmokeFire EX4 is a solid option.
Additional Brands to Consider
While Traeger and Weber are top contenders, other brands like Pit Boss and Green Mountain Grills offer excellent alternatives. Pit Boss is known for its affordability and versatile cooking options, while Green Mountain Grills provides high-tech features and robust performance. Exploring these brands can give you more choices and help you find the perfect pellet grill to meet your needs.